Confusing, Maznah, What Happen ?
Haven't you heard about Maznah's video case tu ? About penjagaan anjing and ucapan hari raya with le dogs ? - google this yourself, I have no intention on showing to you with something that people did wrong.
They said, what Maznah doing is menghina agama.
Okay.
From my opinion.
- Yes, we(muslims) knows that, anjing ialah salah satu perkara yang perlu disamak jika disentuh ketika basah, sebab ia dikategorikan di dalam najis besar, what ? Najis mughollazah ?
- Haram dan halal ? I have never heard that sentuh anjing ialah haram.
Bab membela anjing di dalam rumah, I seen nothing wrong in doing that, but if she let her dogs berjalan dari luar ke dalam ke tempat sembahyang and tempat tempat lain yang boleh meragukan dan membatalkan wuduk dan membuatkan dia dalam keadaan 'tidak bersih dari najis besar', well, that will be a 100% wrong.
It is sad somehow, for how fast people judging other people base on a picture and some video clip.
How about if that Maznah has a less knowledge in Islam ? How would people say that later ? "Kecil kecil tak nak mampus, dah besar menunjukkan bodoh"
- people
About that "Selamat Hari Raya with le dogs" , dia dah buat video dah pun, dan tu pun video penjagaan anjing macam mana, so what people expect actually ? Secara confirm dia tak tahu bahawa ucapan beliau dengan anjing sangatlah tidak boleh diterima masyarakat. Seperti menghisap rokok dibulan puasa, seperti makan kedai mamak time tengah hari di bulan Ramadhan, masyarakat mana terima semua benda ni.
Dalam Islam, apabila seseorang membuat salah yang masih dalam keadaan meragukan, seperti kes Maznah *I don't know what happen in court, lets say she didn't know that what she did will offend so much* we should give her support, not by saying she is menghina agama and so on, she is one of us.
By support not by let him doing what was she doing tu, tapi bagi nasihat, denda yang tidak membebankan, bagi cadangan yang membina, that will make her happy in a good way walaupun dia kena denda and people knew what she did. And other people will know this too right ? I mean, not just her he only muslim, yang membela anjing di rumah, like seriously, there are a lot of em outside there.
Anjing, is dangerous. An adult dog can kill a human male adult. Built a place for it, outside the house, away from children or has no reach to harm any people, might do.
She has a good intention, but a wrong way of doing it. Saving starving stray dogs or injured dog are good aite people ? Way more better then leaving the dogs rotten to death at the side of the street and let us smell that cute smell whenever we pass through it.
cat and dog, the different are, dangerous or not and kena samak bila sentuh time basah or tak.
Some other said "Don't put Maznah in doghouse for being kind"
Come, let hear this from you pulak. I think, saya ada salah di satu tempat, but I don't know where it is.
Totally agree with ur opinion.we as a muslims cannot simply judge her.bear in mind that she has a very good intention I.e to help the dogs.shehas nointention to create such a huge conflict like this..
ReplyDeleteOne more thing we as a humble human being cannot simply said wat is sins wat is not..:)
what is sins, and what is not. That is a good point! :D
ReplyDeleteklu tak silap den, video tu diupload 3 tahun lepas kan? still people try to make this cheap point to blame people, marah marah, hukum diorang.
ReplyDeletewhatever it is, stop la membenci sama kita. klu betul diorng slah. let law decide, klu law dunia tak dapat decide, biar law di akhirat yang decide.. kita bukan god, tak tau pun niat sebenar di hati dia..
yup yup. 3 tahun lepas, baru sekarang nak heboh.
ReplyDeleteDaripada Sufyan bin Abu Zuhair, bahawa Nabi SAW bersabda: Barang siapa memelihara anjing bukan untuk menjaga ladang atau ternak, maka setiap hari pahalanya berkurangan satu qirath. (riwayat Bukhari dan Muslim dan semua ahli hadis yang lain.
ReplyDeletelike this topic lah.
ReplyDeleteWould you please explain to us more ?
ReplyDeleteWhat should we (muslims) do to the injured and starving stray dog ?
just by copy and pasting that hadith didn't enlightening anything.
From my reading, it tell us that, we can keep the dog, but for the only and only purpose of guarding, not as binatang peliharaan (pet?).
whatever it is, please dont be on either side..
ReplyDeleteto me, it's not proper to bela anjing di dalam rumah tmpt kita smayang dan buat aktvti harian. rasulullah tak pernah kata bela anjing tu haram. orang islam harus bela anjing dengan tujuan untuk mengembala ternakan dan mengawal harta benda seperti anjing ditugaskan untuk menjaga rumah orang jaya dari dirompak penjahat. tapi bukan bela anjing dalam rumah. tak kira la spesis apa pun, chihuahua ke, anjing bulldog ke, dalmatian ke, anjing comel macam hachi ke. nehi hey. asalkan bukan dalam rumah!! nak bela dalam rumah kucing je lahhh.... huhu... itu pendapat saya setelah saya dengar ceramah2 ustaz terkemuka. harap dibetulkan jika ada salah
ReplyDelete